If it's another case of a monster going out of control, there might not be any real rhyme or reason to it.

I find that hard to believe when it was just four of us on the beach last night. Someone woulda had to cross paths with him, and--

[ and what? that still isn't a real reason or explanation. but he doesn't finish that thought because haha!! he sure is going through it!! ]

I think there were probably a lot of us staying on the island. They might not have had to go that far to run into him.

...Though I know Pickles was planning on going back to the village, so. I don't know.

[ how many murders were they dealing with ]